ICANN is not concerned that DropZone presents significant security, stability, or competition issues.
ICANN Vice President, GDD Accounts and Services Russ Weinstein has informed TurnCommerce that it sees no problems with Donuts’ plans for its DropZone service. Weinstein said Donuts’ plans do not raise significant security, stability, or competition concerns.
Donuts filed two Registry Services Evaluation Policy (RSEP) requests (pdf, pdf) with ICANN for the DropZone system.
With Dropzone, the registry provides an exact expiration time for each domain, and registrars can apply for the domains at this time through a discrete EPP server system. If more than one registrar sends an application, the domain is awarded to the first registrar that submits its application on or after the expiration time.
TurnCommerce co-founder Jeff Reberry expressed concerns about the system and the precedent it could set. Apparently, Donuts intends to charge a small fee for DropZone orders. It’s unclear if the fee will be success-based or application-based.
While few people will be concerned about a fee for Donuts’ domains, this could give .com registry Verisign an opening to find a way to extract revenue from the expired domain process.
Verisign has previously tried to grab more revenue from expired domains with a “waitlist” service. The company has also patented other ways to distribute expired domains, including offering encoded backorder domains and creating access pools for catching expired domains.
It is basically all one organization
The CEO of Donuts, worked for ICANN as President of GDD…. Do you even hav to wonder how much influence he has? Same with Fadi Chehade trying to take over .ORG… ex-CEO of ICANN. If you worked for ICANN at one point your new organization has the green light.