Company used Amazon Turk to survey people about the meaning of a term.
Domain name seller HugeDomains used a unique approach in a recent UDRP response.
Oil and gas company Tenaris Connections BV filed the dispute against the domain Temaris.com, which is one letter off from the company’s Tenaris.com domain.
HugeDomains had a lot going for it in this case. It didn’t point the domain to competing ads and apparently capitalized the domain on the landing page as TeMaris.com.
“Te” is a common pronoun in many languages.
To bolster its argument that it had no idea who the complainant was when it registered the domain, HugeDomains used Amazon mTurk to survey people about what “temaris” meant to them. No respondents mentioned the oil and gas company. Amazon’s Mechanical Turk is a fast and cheap way to get feedback from a large crowd.
This is a clever idea.
The panel didn’t put too much weight on the survey results but did consider it:
In reaching this conclusion the Panel has not attributed significant weight to the Amazon survey the Respondent relies upon (above) as it does not know enough about exactly how it was conducted. The Panel is however struck by the fact that it would seem that not a single person responding to the survey identified the Complainant or the TENARIS trademark in his or her answer, which seems consistent with the Panel’s view (above) as to the specialized sector the Complainant operates in.
One of the three World Intellectual Property Organization panelists found this to be a case of reverse domain name hijacking. The other two gave Tenaris a pass:
…However in circumstances where the Complainant is seeking to be vigilant to prevent “typosquatting” in relation to its name, and where it has succeeded in previous UDRP cases (albeit with materially different facts) the majority are not persuaded the Complainant’s conduct falls within the above guidelines nor that it deserves the censure of a finding of RDNH.
The most baffling part of this case to me is that Tenaris pursued legal action when the domain was listed for sale for only $3,195. It had a flimsly case to begin with and likely spent well more than the asking price between filing and legal fees.
Richard says
I bet the lawyers charged Tenaris a cool $15k and are laughing in their sleep…
Probably trying to convince them to go ahead with a court filing for another $50k retainer as we speak.