Domain name investors alerted domain owner to possible theft.
The original registrant of Calculator.com has filed a lawsuit (pdf) to recover the domain name, which it says was stolen from it. [See case update here.]
Chloe Tsakiris Alston says that she and her father registered the domain in 1997 and then developed it. The lawsuit states that the site generates $10,000 a month in Adsense revenue.
In 2018, the domain was listed in an auction on Sedo. Several domain name investors, including George Kirikos and Jamie Zoch, reached out to Alston to let her know the domain was being auctioned and to verify that the domain wasn’t stolen. The winning bidder of the auction also contacted her for verification before wiring payment for the $250,000 winning bid.
At that point, Alston contacted the domain name registrar, Network Solutions. According to the lawsuit, Network Solutions stopped a domain transfer to the alleged thief but kept the thief’s contact information associated with the domain. The alleged thief then transferred the domain to GoDaddy. It has apparently been sold since then and the new owner is also named in the lawsuit.
Alston is now trying to get the domain back through the lawsuit.
Oddly, Alston filed the lawsuit in Florida even though none of the parties are located there. The only reason I can think of for this is that the lawyer is with Recalde Law Firm in Florida. Recalde successfully recovered xportautoparts.com by getting a temporary restraining order that ordered the current registrar of that domain to transfer it back to the auto part store’s registrar.
It’s also worth noting that the original sale on Sedo by the thief was thwarted thanks to information in Whois. Several domain investors thought the sale was suspicious and were able to contact the true owner because of Whois information. This information is going away due to changes in the wake of GDPR.
Matt says
How do people think they can get away with this?
Andrew Allemann says
It’s possible that the thief already got away with it. It looks like the sold the domain to someone else, which means they probably have the money and are nowhere to be found.
Richard says
Sedo auction + Network Solutions as registrar is the mother of all red flags. Avoid it like the plague.
Tony says
Damn. I was the 2nd highest bidder in that Sedo auction. I tried contacting the owner through the site’s contact form during the auction and never got a reply which was suspicious. Great domain and I hope the rightful owner gets it back.
pastebin says
Crazy thinks happens…
Kushal says
Can Someone please help me in understanding how domain theft happens? Is it password phising for domain registrar account?sorry if noob question
Andrew Allemann says
In this case, the lawsuit alleges that the person send forged documents to Network Solutions.