Featured Domains


U.S. Government follows up on “cooling off period” idea for ICANN employees

NTIA chief wants ICANN to restrict post-ICANN employment.

Following up on remarks made during ICANN 63 in Barcelona last week, National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) head David Redl sent a letter to ICANN Friday criticizing people leaving the regulator for industry companies.

Redl first mentioned the concern publicly last week in comments during the meeting. His interest in the subject presumably stems from Donuts hiring Akram Atallah as its new CEO. Atallah led the Global Domains Division at ICANN.

Here’s the text of Redl’s letter to ICANN:

NTIA continues to be a strong supporter of the multistakeholder approach to Internet Governance, including through our participation as the U.S. representative to the Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC) at the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN). Paramount to the success of the multistakeholder approach is trust in the institutions that make decisions about the Internet’s future. While the community has greatly improved ICANN’s accountability through the IANA stewardship transition process, I am writing to raise a concern about an accountability deficit at ICANN.

Recent ICANN senior staff departures have highlighted that ICANN lacks postemployment restrictions. Given that ICANN, through the enforcement of its contracts with domain name registries and registrars, performs an industry self-regulatory function, it is necessary that conflicts of interest or appearance of unethical behavior be minimized. While the United States will recommend this issue be addressed in the third iteration of ICANN’s Accountability and Transparency Review Team (ATRT3), which we expect to have had its initial meeting no later than June 2019, I encourage you to look into this now. One potential fix could be “cooling off periods” for ICANN employees that accept employment with companies involved in ICANN activities and programs. This is an ethical way to ensure that conflicts of interest or appearances of unethical behavior are minimized.

One challenge I foresee is that ICANN sometimes hires people from the industry because of their specialized knowledge. It might be difficult to attract these people if they can’t return to industry companies. ICANN would need to compensate them for the restriction. I also wonder if employment laws in various states and countries would limit the ability to enforce cooling off provisions.

The most in-depth analysis of the global domain market

Get Our Newsletter

Stay up-to-date with the latest analysis and news about the domain name industry by joining our mailing list.

No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Reader Interactions


    Leave a Comment

  1. John says

    ICANN should be 80% run by domain investors as they are just about the only ones that understand this industry.

    Almost everyone at ICANN is clueless about domain names — they are mostly techies with no grasp on the issues of what they are talking about. They don’t understand how the domain market works or what would be best for the public. Additionally, they have a really poor grasp of how business works and don’t make decisions that are pro-business. They do only what they want and ignore community comments.

    They are literally the worst, most unqualified people to run ICANN — yet they get these jobs that pay an astronomical salary.

    Many of them make over 400K a year…..how abusive is that for a non-profit?

    • kd says

      Yet the article asks/states “ICANN would need to compensate them for the restriction.”

      I agree with you John, compensation is already there, enough, and too much.

  2. Hal says

    I love the comment “they ignore community comments”
    Meaning they ignore my comments .

    Love to hear what comments or input domain investors submitted that were ignored by ICANN

  3. Vanda Scartezini says

    Totally agree with the general idea of “ quarantine” period for higher level employeesat ICANN

Domain Name Wire | Domain Name News
%d bloggers like this: