Businessman Sets Up UDRPfail.com After Losing Domain Dispute
Tuesday, April 28th, 2009
Man loses DEACOM.com despite overwhelming evidence of rights and fair use.
Businessman Ben Dean lost a UDRP this month for deacom.com, a domain name he’s owned since 1997 and used for his business. He says he can’t afford to fight the action in court, but set up UDRPfail.com to tell the world about his predicament.
A company filed a trademark for DEACOM in 2006, claiming first use in commerce in 1995. It decided to file the arbitration case to get the corresponding domain name.
Dean registered the domain name in 1997 and started using it for business and personal uses. He is a sole proprietor operating under the name DEACOM. He even had a corporation DEACOM Inc from 2002-2006 registered in New Jersey. He has used the domain name for e-mail throughout, most recently using Google Apps. He provided the arbitration panel with screenshots of his Gmail inbox that he uses with the e-mail ben@deacom.com to the panel, along with the relevant incorporation documents.
But National Arbitration Forum arbitrator Estella S. Gold seemed to ignore the evidence and Dean’s use of the domain name, stating “The Panel agrees with Complainant’s assertion that Respondent has not utilized the disputed domain name in an active manner.” Apparently the use of a domain for e-mail and business purposes is not a legitimate use.
If Dean would have hired a good UDRP lawyer to handle his case he probably would have won. But you can read all of the documents in the case on Dean’s web site. It sure seems that the evidence was overwhelmingly in his favor.


















